On April 18, 2017, the Trump Administration released an executive order addressing federal guestworker visa programs. Below is a statement by National Guestworker Alliance (NGA) Executive Director Saket Soni:
“Today’s executive order threatens to erode the rights both of guestworkers, and of U.S. workers in similar jobs, on the pretext of protecting only the latter. ‘Buy American, Hire American,’ coupled with the anti-immigrant hysteria this administration encourages, is deadly. Trump’s economic nationalism creates a false ‘us,’ while his deportation force creates a false ‘them.’ The result is that all workers lose.
“The order issued today falsely blames migrant workers for the impacts of unregulated labor markets and rampant corporate globalization. Guestworkers make tremendous sacrifices to come to the U.S. and perform necessary jobs far from their families, with little stability and often in deplorable conditions. These workers must be protected from exploitation both for their own sake, and to prevent a race to the bottom with U.S. workers.
“Trump’s latest executive order is confusing and opaque, directing actions that seem aimed at placing employer interests over worker rights. The order opens a path for federal agencies to roll back the protections in guestworker programs that are already insufficient to secure the basic rights of guestworkers or their U.S. counterparts.
“The order fails to address the rampant abuse of guestworkers outside the H-1B program, such as the widespread forced labor conditions the NGA has exposed in the H-2B and J-1 visa programs. It also threatens to eliminate all parole programs, which have permitted the discretionary admission of immigrants for humanitarian purposes. This could immediately cancel the status of thousands of immigrants who are currently lawfully present in the United States for humanitarian purposes—dividing families, undermining human rights, and creating chaos.
“No overhaul of guestworker programs will succeed unless it empowers guestworkers to report workplace abuse, and protects them from immigration-related threats. All federal agencies connected to workplace regulation should be consulting with worker voice organizations to understand the realities workers face on the ground.
“Basic human and civil rights in the workplace cannot be parceled out by visa category, industry, national origin, or immigration status. The rights of U.S. workers will only be secure when the rights and dignity of migrant workers in the U.S. are secure as well.”